Papers hope to profit from online partnerships
So you think you can profit off of online employment ads?
That question may be
answered sooner than later following a flurry of partnerships between
newspapers and Internet vendors.
One reason for the
activity: newspapers’ print revenue and circulation figures continue to
slide while online penetration shows vigorous signs of life.
Case in point:
Newspaper Association of America figures that reported that newspapers
collected $638 million in online ad revenues for the third quarter of
2006, a 23 percent boost.
What’s more, the group
also reported that newspapers are attracting more affluent readers to
their Web sites. A recent report by Scarborough Research examining the
sites of five newspapers indicated that their readers were more likely
than other Internet users to spend upwards of $1,000 each month online.
The rise in online
readership and ad revenue has spurred some of new media’s biggest forces
to secure partnerships with newspaper publishers.
“Industry analysts
agree with us that the local advertising opportunity is tremendous,”
said Hilary Schneider, senior vice president of Yahoo Marketplace, about
the site’s alliance with eight major newspaper publishers.
The new partnership
will make a big difference in the way companies advertise and the way
they interact with consumers, she added.
“We believe the local
segment is largely untapped and provides significant opportunities to
expand audience engagement and grow local advertising.”
During the
teleconference announcing the partnership, Schneider hailed the
projected growth of online advertising, citing one Bank of America study
predicting the U.S. online advertising market to more than triple to
$12.4 billion by 2010.
Leading positions
“This partnership
advances Yahoo’s strategy of securing leading positions where we see the
biggest prospects for growth,” she said. “As we all know, both the print
and online versions newspapers remain one of the consumer’s most trusted
sources for local content and are the major force in the local media
marketplace.”
The new partnership
also includes plans to mesh Yahoo and newspaper features, such as
newspapers displaying Yahoo maps while Yahoo carries newspaper-created
content on its local sites.
Not everyone is as
sanguine about the partnership’s future, however. Classified
Intelligence, while generally lauding the deal, said papers have to wait
and see if members will actually result in an increase in traffic once
Yahoo begins incorporating a newspaper’s content on its own site.
Still, said Classified
Intelligence principal and contributing editor John Zappe, the alliance
represents a step forward from current advertising efforts. Newspapers
will have the backing of Yahoo’s sales force and its IT infrastructure
will manage both national and local ad campaigns sold by newspaper
staffers, he wrote.
“That moves well
beyond what Real Cities now does, enabling an advertiser to buy the
network or just parts of it or even just certain parts of a newspaper
site,” Zappe said in an analyst’s note assessing the partnership.
But he also wrote that
newspaper companies have ceded a part of their independence in exchange
for some short-term gain.
“Now that might sound
like a negative, but it is not intended as such,” he said. “Short-term
gains, to the extent they can be converted into a long-term strategic
opportunity, should not be denigrated.”
-Marcelo Duran
Yahoo one of many
internet alliances
In the past few months, a number of high-profile Internet companies have
teamed up with newspapers in an effort to help publishers tap into the
online employment ad marketplace.
A rundown:
*Eight major
publishers, consisting of more than 200 newspapers ranging from The
Denver Post and St. Louis Post-Dispatch to The Dallas Morning News and
Atlanta Journal-Constitution, in November teamed up with Yahoo Inc. to
form an online network offering co-branded employment classified sites
to readers.
The first phase of the
partnership will provide advertisers who list jobs in any of the
consortium’s newspapers the capability to post their jobs on Yahoo
HotJobs and throughout the Yahoo network.
Long-term plans
include the ability to share content and Internet features between Yahoo
and consortium newspaper members.
*Monster made headway
in the newspaper market last summer when the recruitment company
announced its joint venture with Philadelphia Media Holdings LLC,
publisher of The Philadelphia Inquirer and Philadelphia Daily News, to
launch a co-branded job site.
Following that
partnership, more than 40 other newspapers have hopped on the Monster
bandwagon, including the Akron (Ohio) Beacon Journal, the Honolulu
Star-Bulletin, the Wilkes-Barre (Pa.) Times-Leader and papers owned by
Freedom Communications Inc. and North Jersey Media Group.
*Employment Web site
CareerBuilder.com, which is owned by Gannett Co. Inc., Tribune
Publishing and McClatchy Co., recently finalized an agreement over the
ownership of the site following McClatchy’s acquisition of Knight Ridder.
Under terms of the
revised pact, Gannett and Tribune each increased its equity stake in
CareerBuilder to 42.5 percent while McClatchy retained a 15 percent
share. Gannett and Tribune paid McClatchy more than $300 million as part
of the transaction.
Twenty of the
newspapers McClatchy acquired from Knight Ridder were already affiliated
with CareerBuilder. Twelve other McClatchy newspapers, including The
Sacramento (Calif.) Bee and (Minneapolis) Star Tribune, will now become
part of the job site, bringing to more than 150 the number of papers now
part of CareerBuilder.com.
*The PAGE Co-op
entered the fray by taking an equity ownership in a new employment
classified ad company, The Job Network LLC. Other partners in the
network are TownNews.com and Redmatch North America.
TownNews.com and
Redmatch’s current joint venture, The Job Network, will be folded into
the new The Job Network. PAGE members will be allowed to purchase equity
shares of The Job Network LLC. The member-owned co-op serves more than
550 daily newspapers with a total circulation of more than 12 million.
*Google is conducting
a three-month test between 100 of its current advertisers and more than
50 daily newspapers to allow businesses to buy ads in newspapers (see
Newspapers & Technology, December 2006). While Google is not working
with newspapers to sell online employments ads, the pilot project is
aimed at attracting online advertisers and smaller marketers to the
print medium.
-Marcelo Duran |