The numbers are frightening down
40 percent, down 45 percent, down 30 percent.
Newspapers have seen a sharp decline
in employment advertising revenue since the beginning of the year some of
them as much as 50 percent below the numbers from a year earlier and the
picture is not good.
Although we are finding that many
newspapers are adding to their print classified advertising revenue though sales
of their online services, employment advertising is vulnerable more than any
other category to economic and demographic forces that are changing both
newspaper business models and individuals interactions with media.
For instance, where are college
graduates looking for jobs? Not in the newspaper.
A survey of the Class of 2001 by
Vault.com (albeit, a biased source with a self-selected online pool of
respondents) shows that 76 percent said they did not find print classifieds
helpful. Where did they look? Company Web sites was the top choice (55 percent),
followed by corporate recruiting events (45 percent), college career centers (44
percent) and online job boards (also 44 percent).
Even the Newspaper Association of
America (presumably less biased than Vault.com, but still not a dispassionate
observer) reported in its survey of changing media habits that 78 percent of the
adults surveyed rely on daily and Sunday newspapers for employment advertising.
That means nearly one-quarter of all those responding said they do not rely on
the newspaper for employment ads.
How will newspapers recover their
market share? They wont. Its as simple as that. Newspapers will never
again have the market share in employment advertising that they had a few years
ago.
Yet and heres the important
paradox they have the opportunity to increase their revenue in the
employment advertising category, and to strengthen their ties to employers, job
seekers and their local markets.
Unfortunately for dyed-in-the-wool
were a newspaper types, it means newspapers have to do more than just
publish their daily or weekly print editions.
To increase revenue in this
important and lucrative category, newspapers will need to:
Offer employers applicant
tracking systems and multimedia posting systems, helping those advertisers with
new ways to manage their hiring processes and to reach prospective employees.
Partner with other media in
their markets, like radio stations and television stations, or beat them as
head-on competitors for employment dollars.
Develop new media choices to
offer employers, such as online job sites, separate weekly or monthly print
employment publications, direct-mail programs, niche-employment products in
fields like health care and technology, virtual and on-site career fairs and
more.
Improve, expand and better
promote their existing print employment services.
Those are just a few of the steps
newspapers will need to take to hang on to and more importantly, increase
employment revenue.
The AIM Group and Classified
Intelligence recently completed a three-month study of employment advertising,
and found that new competitors are taking a permanent chunk out of revenue that
used to belong to the local newspaper. Nearly three-quarters of all radio
stations in the United States are now pursuing employment ad revenue.
Monster.com and technology niche
site Dice.com are among the profitable online job boards, and literally
thousands of other sites are chasing employment ad dollars. Unlike dot-coms that
rely primarily on ad revenue and have thus seen their coffers dry up, employment
sites have a different, and more effective, business model, generating revenue
from employers.
All of these changes are part of the
media revolution thats under way now. Dont make the mistake of thinking of
it as an evolution, its much faster and more threatening than that.
If your newspaper has realized youre
going to have to become the local information source in your market, regardless
of the medium or platform on which you deliver that information, youre well
on your way to overcoming short-term revenue losses. Youre in a position to
expand your business in new ways during the next few years and beyond.
If employment revenue is important
to you, and even at small weeklies it can represent a significant percentage of
revenue, focus on it for the next few months by developing an aggressive program
of new employment services.
Your business will benefit, both in
the short term and for the foreseeable future.
Peter Zollman is founding
principal of Advanced Interactive Media Group L.L.C., a consulting group that
works with newspapers and other media companies to develop profitable
interactive services. He can be reached at 407.788.2780 or via e-mail at pzollman@group-aim.com.
For more information about the
report, Help Wanted: Survivors Guide to Employment Advertising Revenue,
visit www.aimgroup.com/reports.